A recent update to the New York City Department of Housing Preservation and Development (“HPD”) Marketing Handbook allows HPD to fill any affordable housing units that have not been leased-up through the initial lottery process with homeless shelter referrals (“Unrented Affordable Units”). This guideline change repeals the right that was previously available to developers to remarket Unrented Affordable Units through open market listings.
The new marketing guideline also revokes a developer’s unqualified right to remarket Unrented Affordable Units through a second lottery unless HPD consents, in its sole discretion. HPD has indicated that, at most, it will only permit developers to remarket a portion of the Unfilled Units in a project through a second lottery, and only if the Unrented Affordable Units are “a large number or percentage of units in the project,” and “[d]epending on the number of unleased units and the mix of affordable and/or market rate units in the building.” (Q&A released by HPD entitled Homeless Referrals for Remarketed Units: Fact Sheet for Owners and Marketing Agents).
Based on the latest advice from HPD, the Unrented Affordable Units must comprise at least 15 percent of the total units in the building before HPD will consider a second lottery. By way of example, if a building contains 100 units, 25 of which are required to be affordable, and there are 10 Unrented Affordable Units following the initial lottery, HPD will not permit a second lottery, given that the Unrented Affordable Units comprise only 10 percent of the total units. If, on the other hand, there are 20 Unrented Affordable Units, then HPD may permit all or a portion of those 20 units to be rented through a second lottery, because those units make up more than 15 percent of the total units.
The affordable marketing guideline change was implemented as an additional tool to address the homeless crisis that currently plagues New York City. It is also HPD’s strategy to encourage developers to initially market affordable housing units at lower rents, notwithstanding that higher rents might be permitted under Affordable New York (affordable to families earning up to 130 percent AMI).
Even developers who completed the initial lottery prior to the change remain subject to the new marketing guidelines, despite not having had prior notice that they would be unable to remarket Unrented Affordable Units in the open market or through a second lottery.
Seiden & Schein, P.C. has strategies that developers can take that might work to reduce the impact of the new marketing guidelines. For further information, please contact Alvin Schein email@example.com Jason Hershkowitz firstname.lastname@example.org or David Shamshovich email@example.com by email or by phone at (212) 935-1400.